Wikipedia ‘Brain Surgery’ Myth

There’s an excellent post on Techdirt rebuking the typical “Professor Bans Wikipedia” meme that seems to creep into the news cycle every few weeks. This time it’s Deakin University associate professor of information systems Sharman Lichtenstein:

If you are faced with the prospect of having brain surgery, who would you rather it be performed by – a surgeon trained at medical school or someone who has read Wikipedia?

My immediate reaction was, “What is this, a Holiday Inn Express commercial?”

Techdirt’s Mike Masnick has an excellent retort:

…no one would want a brain surgery based on someone who just learned how to do brain surgery from Wikipedia, but that proves absolutely nothing. No one would want brain surgery done by someone who just learned how to do brain surgery from Encyclopedia Britannica either — but you don’t see this professor freaking out and trashing Britannica, do you? Wikipedia is a tool, just like Britannica, and it’s not designed to be a reference on how to do brain surgery.

I hope we can all point to that blog posting every time this silly argument comes up, which seems all too often.

Nepal… Tibet… whatever…

Just when you thought the US was simply a bit confused about the Middle East (Sunni-Shia, Iraq-Iran and all that) Stephen Hadley, national security advisor to President Bush, flubs it regarding Tibet.

Interviewed on this ABC News This Week, he says “Nepal” instead of “Tibet” more than a “half-dozen times“. But don’t take my word for it, see the video and transcript here. (ABC News had to put “sic” in multiple times to explain the oddity).

“The way to deal with the issue of Nepal (sic) is not by some — a statement that you’re not going to the opening ceremonies and say, therefore, I checked the Nepal (sic)box.”

Instead, Hadley said the President is opting to pursue a broader diplomatic approach. “What he’s doing on Nepal (sic) is what we think the international community ought to be doing, which is approaching the Chinese privately through diplomatic channels and sending a very firm message of concern for human rights, a concern for what’s happening in Nepal (sic), urging the Chinese government to understand that it is in their interest to reach out to representatives of the Dalai Lama, and to show, while the whole world is watching China, that they are determined to treat their citizens with dignity and respect. There is an opportunity here.”

If you remember, it was Stephen Hadley who as deputy national security advisor admitted responsibility for the “16 words” about yellowcake uranium that slipped into Bush’s 2003 State of the Union address. Of course we all know now it turned out to be false. Afterwards, he submitted his resignation to the president, but Bush did not accept it and instead, he’s now top national security advisor.

Wikipedia and Blogspot available in China

Not known for their sense of humor, the Chinese authorities chose April Fools day to unblock Wikipedia and Blogspot and netizens in the PRC are rejoicing. Danwei, Kaiser Kuo and CNET had the scoop. This past month saw both YouTube and BBC News unblocked as well. Ironic, considering the recent unrest in T%bet.

The downside is that Chinese Wikipedia (zh.wikipedia.org) is still blocked, through the filtering of its “host header.” For the tech inclined, here are examples of the block in action showing how de: (German Wikipedia) works fine, but zh: does not:

SUCCESS

$ wget –header “Host: de.wikipedia.org” http://203.212.189.253
–2008-04-03 01:22:54–  http://203.212.189.253/
Connecting to 203.212.189.253:80… connected.
HTTP request sent, awaiting response… 301 Moved Permanently
Location: http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hauptseite [following]
–2008-04-03 01:22:55–  http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hauptseite
Resolving de.wikipedia.org… 203.212.189.253
Reusing existing connection to 203.212.189.253:80.
HTTP request sent, awaiting response… 200 OK
Length: 34452 (34K) [text/html]
Saving to: `Hauptseite’

100%[=======================================>] 34,452      38.0K/s   in 0.9s

2008-04-03 01:22:57 (38.0 KB/s) – `Hauptseite’ saved [34452/34452]

FAILURE

$ wget –header “Host: zh.wikipedia.org” http://203.212.189.253
–2008-04-03 01:23:02–  http://203.212.189.253/
Connecting to 203.212.189.253:80… connected.
HTTP request sent, awaiting response… Read error (Connection reset by peer) in headers.
Retrying.